Featured post

NBA Playoffs 2026- Conference Finals Game 1-4 (Monday 18th May-Monday 25th May)

We are going to be down to the final four teams in the NBA once Game 7 of the Second Round Series between the Detroit Pistons and Cleveland ...

Showing posts with label Liverpool v Manchester United. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Liverpool v Manchester United. Show all posts

Friday, 20 October 2017

United Corner- Mourinho's Detractors Out in Force (October 20th)

United Corner- Mourinho's Detractors Out in Force
What did people really expect from Manchester United's trip to Anfield?

I was more surprised that so many were 'shocked' and 'upset' by Jose Mourinho's tactics in the first game out of the international break, especially when you could almost select the first eleven which started the game (maybe Anthony Martial over Marcus Rashford was the only real surprising choice).

Don't get me wrong, I would have loved for Mourinho to have come out all guns blazing and take the game to Liverpool, but that is the heart speaking and not the head. Essentially I have been saying for over twelve months to anyone who may care that Liverpool are a team you need to contain for the first half hour, especially at Anfield, and then try and pick them off and you could see from the Mourinho tactics the manager felt the same.

Heck, even Bryan Robson had said the same thing at a Q&A I attended the day before the trip to Anfield so I was not at all surprised that Mourinho's first thought was to make sure United didn't fall behind too early and then need to chase a game where Liverpool could hit them on the break.

That was achieved thanks to some quality goalkeeping from David De Gea, but this is where I think the criticism of Mourinho for 'parking the bus' from some in the media, as well as some United fans, plus from the opposite manager has been used as a smoke and mirrors attempt from Jurgen Klopp.

For all the perceived 'negative' tactics that Mourinho supposedly employed, Jurgen Klopp seems to be given a pass because he looks like a cartoon character.

I mean has everyone glossed over the fact he took off his three first choice attacking players for the likes of Daniel Sturridge, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Dominic Solanke...

Those were like for like changes as Klopp was just as concerned in wanting to avoid a defeat as Mourinho was, yet the 'story' goes that the Liverpool manager is this attacking stalwart who has been denied by a negative defensive manager who simply didn't want to win the game.

During the second half I was convinced Liverpool were going to try and take the game to United by taking off one of their midfield trio, move Coutinho into that space and bring on another attacking player. I mean Klopp suggests his team were doing all the attacking so why not take that risk and go for the win?

Instead Klopp decided he didn't really want to risk going for the three points and lose the game, something which actually went against Mourinho's thinking as he had brought on pace for the counter attack into spaces he thought would be there when his opposite number went for the win.

So the game petered out and it is Mourinho who takes all the criticism for the performances, while Klopp continues to be this proponent of attacking football. It's a nonsense when you actually sit down and look at the way the two teams approached the game and the substitutions made, while this myth about Sir Alex's 'free flowing' football continue to be peddled by the media.


It was Craig Bellamy who was the latest to try and tell United fans what is, and what is not, acceptable in the brand of football being played. You could almost forget that only Manchester City have scored more goals than Manchester United this season or the fact that United have 6 more League goals than Tottenham Hotspur and 8 more than Liverpool and Chelsea.

Sir Alex himself was playing plenty of 'pragmatic' football in his later years at Manchester United and trips to Anfield were not that much fun over the last few years under his watch.

Yes I did want United to try and get further up the pitch, but I think the Liverpool tactics didn't help and when two teams are happy to take a point then this is the kind of game you get.

The only difference seems to be that Jose Mourinho's 'negative' image is the one that gets bandied around the papers while others can throw in a 'boom' every now and then and are beloved for it.


Manchester United also added another three points in the Champions League with a vital win at Benfica during the week and it was another game that was perhaps not the free flowing games the fans have become used to this season.

But it was job done and we have to be happy about that.

During the course of a long season there will be the peaks and troughs in level of performance and the key is to find a way to win when not playing at your best. It didn't happen at Anfield, but I don't know when gaining a point from that ground was considered such a 'negative' result, while the win at Benfica was a case of doing enough and preserving some energy.

The big games keep coming for United with a trip to Huddersfield Town followed by a home game against Tottenham Hotspur and then what is likely to be a tetchy affair at Chelsea. A home game in the Champions League against Benfica can confirm United's place in the Last 16 of that competition before the trip to Stamford Bridge.

I expect the League games against Spurs and Chelsea to be tight affairs as most of the fixtures against the top teams will be, but I think United have to be looking at coming away with at least four points against those two teams.

Don't be surprised if Mourinho does play a similar tactic at Stamford Bridge to the one he used at Liverpool, although Antonio Conte will likely get a pass if he uses the same system he did against Manchester City and the game does not ignite like the neutrals and pundits would love to see.


At this stage of the season I am simply looking for United to keep in touch with those lot across Manchester but I won't be criticising Mourinho if he makes sure we are solid and hard to beat in the fixtures coming up. That will give United the platform for success as some of the injuries clear up to once again provide rotation for the manager.

It is a big month before the next international break, but one I am confident United can negotiate with success.

Wednesday, 19 September 2012

United Corner September 18th (Wigan, Galatasaray and Liverpool)


This is a new 'corner' I have added to the blog that will be devoted to my first passion in life, Manchester United. I will publish this, on most occasions, on a Sunday evening where I will look back at the previous week, giving my take on results and upcoming fixtures.

All views expressed will be my own.


I don't know what kind of bad luck charm I have picked up recently, but both of my trips to Old Trafford this season has seen me moving at a brisk pace to get to the ground after parking the car thanks to a horrendous amount of traffic on the roads.

After watching the first half of the game at Wigan Athletic, it wouldn't have been like I had missed much after what was a disappointing and often disjointed performance.

As tepid and insomniac curing as the first half had been, the second was a complete contrast as wave after wave of United attack looked like it was going to bring goals for the side. Nani has his critics at Old Trafford, but it would be nice if the fans get off his back a little and try and support and cajole a performance out of him.

He had a terrible first half, but was very good in the second as the whole team increased their tempo and looked more threatening going forward.

Nick Powell had a good cameo, but it is when we aren't winning games that I will look to judge his impact, while Alexander Buttner had a solid debut at left back. Buttner was good going forward, but I found his positioning to be a little suspect when trying to defend, while he was rash in the tackle so there is still some work to be done that won't be exposed in games against Wigan at home.

Overall it was a solid performance in the end and the bonus of picking up our first clean sheet of the season is a positive to take forward, although I am expecting much bigger tests from the two games we have remaining this week.


The biggest thing coming out of the game this weekend wasn't the performances of the debutants, but the chants that came early in the game directed at Liverpool.

'It's Never Your Fault' isn't directed at Hillsborough and all that happened there, despite some in the media quickly pointing to that, but it was ill-timed and not well thought out by the fans who decided to go with it.

Even Sir Alex mentioned that the chants are not making light of what happened at Hillsborough, but we shouldn't have given anyone the chance to criticise this club and the fans who have been through it all in the past.

We all know what kind of chants United fans are subjected to about Munich whenever we play at Anfield, Elland Road or the Council House, but we had always been bigger than that and the 'Where's Your Famous Munich Song' chant at Anfield makes our point loud and clear.

Now we have given up the moral high-ground, even if we weren't making reference to what happened in April 1989.


On a related, but unrelated matter- what has happened to Joe Jordan that he has become deaf and blind? He claims he never heard any Munich chants during his time playing for United... That is quite astonishing as looking back at any tapes pre-1989 will show the banners that were regularly carried around grounds from opposition fans, especially the Liverpool fans.

I wish Gattuso had given him a slap around his head a couple of years ago if only to jog his clearly flagging memory!!


The Champions League will kick off this week as we host Galatasaray and I hope Fergie sticks to his word of having learnt from the mistakes of last season and he will be starting a strong side. I've never understood the need for too much rotation at this stage, unless it is a Tuesday night game off the back of a game against one of the top six sides in the Premier League, and surely it makes much more sense to get 10-12 points from our opening four games and then resting players in the last couple of games.

We have a good chance to do that this time and I would take a big step towards that mark by putting out a side to put Galatasaray to bed early and then bring off a couple of the more vital players in preparation for Liverpool. We do have until Sunday for that game so there are no real excuses and we could also give Darren Fletcher a run out in the last 10 minutes if we are comfortable.

I just don't think we should be under-estimating any team right now, not considering the last home loss in the Champions League came to Turkey's Besiktas.

I'd play: De Gea, Rafael, Evra, Vidic, Ferdinand, Carrick, Cleverley, Valencia, Nani, Kagawa and Van Persie.


Once all the Champions League games are out of the way, we can begin to look forward to the big one at Anfield on Sunday- it is going to be an emotionally draining day for players and fans alike as it is the first game at Anfield since the Hillsborough findings came out, while all the problems around Racist Bastard Number 7 and Patrice Evra are likely to be magnified ahead of the game.

Both clubs are trying to put a lid on the simmering tension, but I think the media's insistence that the United chants were directed at Hillsborough has only increased the heat and I truly hope all fans going to the game get home without getting involved in any issues outside of the ground.

On the playing field, I am nervous as I have tipped Brendan Rodgers' first win as in the League as manager of Liverpool to come in this game against our lads, especially when they blew a big chance to knock of Manchester City at Anfield last month.

We should be too good for them on paper, but they are going to be fired up with the the fans fully behind the team and it is going to be a really tough test for us I feel.

We MUST hold out in the first twenty minutes and try and take the crowd out of the game as that is when Liverpool should come out of the traps very quickly. It will take concentration, but those minutes will be crucial to our chances of picking up the points.

Hopefully the boys can put in a big performance on the pitch and we as fans can show our true Manchester United colours in the stands and show what makes us so great and unique- let us cheer the United boys on and ignore all the bile we are going to encounter from their end and hopefully we can somehow come away with the three points.

I'd play: De Gea, Rafael, Evra, Ferdinand, Vidic, Scholes, Carrick, Cleverley, Valencia, Young and Van Persie.